HAVERHILL — On Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2026, the Haverhill City Council voted against a request for a special permit for the construction of three attached townhouse condominiums on Marshland Street following opposition from neighboring property owners.
Matt Silva of Sterling Commonwealth Builders proposed demolishing an existing single-family house and constructing three attached townhouse condominium units on a single parcel at 27 Marshland Street in the city’s Residential High Zone, which allows one and two-family homes by right and three-family homes by special permit. Each proposed unit would measure approximately 1,700 square feet and include three bedrooms, two and a half bathrooms, an attached two-car garage and two additional driveway parking spaces.
During the meeting, Silva’s attorney, Jonathan Stark-Sachs, from Johnson & Borenstein, LLC in Andover, MA, argued that the roughly 13,000-square-foot property was underutilized and that the project would provide additional owner-occupied housing. He said the city planner recommended approval and outlined landscaping and stormwater improvements intended to address municipal concerns. The project would also require a separate variance for front-yard paving.

Several abutters who spoke in opposition to the project during the meeting said the development doesn’t fit the street’s character, would worsen winter parking and increase runoff. One abutter also objected to the removal of mature, old growth trees, saying they mitigate the heat and wind, hold moisture so runoff isn’t really an issue and filter the air.
“There’s a lot of people in opposition to this. Nobody’s got a problem with them doing what they can do by right, but to build 5,100 square feet of living area, it’s crazy,” said Mark Dickinson, who identified himself as the owner of nearby 30 Marshland Street. “It just doesn’t make sense and it is not appropriate and it is not consistent with the neighborhood that’s existing there today.”
Several councilors agreed that three units would be too much for the site and encouraged the developer to pursue two units, which they said zoning allows by right.
Ward 5 Councilor Shaun Toohey said he could not support the proposal “for the simple fact that the scope is just too large.”
“I think if you shrink that scope to a two-family, I think you have not only the community and the neighbors on board, but…you could do it by right, so you don’t really need us. But I will not support a three-family tonight,” Councilor Toohey added.
Ward 3 Councilor Devan Ferreira, whose ward includes the property, cast the only vote in favor. She argued that the proposal provided substantial off-street parking, would connect to existing public utilities and would help meet the city’s housing needs.
“I think infill housing is our smartest housing that we can invest in as a community right now,” Councilor Ferreira said.
Before the vote, Councilor-at-Large Thomas Sullivan told Silva that rejecting the three-unit proposal would not prevent him from pursuing a two-unit project in the future.
The council then voted 8–1 to reject the proposal. Two councilors were absent.