OXFORD — A Charlton man was arrested Thursday on five counts of animal cruelty after five puppies were found abandoned at three locations in Oxford.
According to the Oxford Police Department, a tip led investigators to determine that the abandoned puppies belonged to a resident of 26 City Depot Road in Charlton. Police said the puppies went missing from that address sometime between Nov. 5 and Nov. 7, 2026.
Following an investigation, an arrest warrant was issued on Nov. 19 for Steven McCarthy, 52, of 26 City Depot Road, Charlton, MA.

Oxford police, assisted by Charlton police, took McCarthy into custody without incident the day the warrant was issued for his arrest.
Oxford police said residents found five puppies, believed to be Cane Corso mixes, at three locations in Oxford on the evening of Nov. 7, 2026: two on Federal Hill Road, two near Clara Barton Road and Main Street, and one on Buffum Dam Road on the Charlton town line.

McCarthy pleaded not guilty to all five counts during his arraignment on Nov. 19 in Dudley District Court, where prosecutors alleged that he tried to sell the puppies online and abandoned them when they did not sell, according to WHDH.
Following his arraignment, McCarthy was released on $1,000 bail under the condition that he have no contact with animals while the case is pending.
McCarthy is due back in court on Dec. 18, 2026.